Date: 28th August 2012 at 6:28pm
Written by:
Wayne Rooney overhead kick


Remember in the 94/95 season when Robbie Fowler made the breakthrough at Liverpool and was scoring goals for fun?

The following season he went on to do even better! He was one of the most gifted finishers the English game has produced. He grew up as an Everton fan. At 26 was sold to Leeds and his career started on a downward spiral. I also remember a 17 year old Michael Owen scoring a consolation goal for Liverpool against Wimbledon, on his debut; the night we won the title. This superstar footballer who was going to break all the records at club and international level. He too grew up as an Everton fan and at 26 he suffered a horrific knee injury playing for England and never recovered. His career has gone downhill ever since.

Now I know that age and boyhood allegiances are tedious links, but at 16 years old Wayne Rooney was billed as the greatest England player of all time. Has he really fulfilled that potential? Would someone outside of England safely put him in the top 25 players in Europe? Let alone top 3.
He was tearing reserve teams apart up and down the country before that, and scored that wonder goal at 16 years against arguably Arséne Wenger’s greatest assembled side. He soon made his England debut and was fearless in the most hostile of environments such as Istanbul. He became on the most expensive teenager in football history on the back of a fantastic Euro 2004, cruelly ended by a broken metatarsal which has haunted him ever since.

When he scored a hat trick on his debut, it was not beyond the realm of doubt that he could become United’s greatest ever player. From when he arrived, until the 2006 World Cup, some even labelled us a one man team, we were so reliant on the young scouser; even though his strike partner was Ruud Van Nistelrooy and we had Cristiano Ronaldo in our ranks. Another broken metatarsal meant he went to a world cup not fully fit and, after a poor tournament and, unsurprisingly give they’re United players, he, along with Cristiano Ronaldo returned as national hate figures following their infamous spat.
Cristiano Ronaldo embraced his newfound status as public enemy number in world football; he was publically denied FIFA Young Player of the Tournament because of his “antics”, and went on to earn what he felt was rightfully his; his status at the world’s best. Rooney just remained United’s second best player.

In 2006/07 we had a record 8 players in the team of the PFA Team of the Year. No Wayne Rooney. In fact he has only ever been in 3 in his career. Steven Gerrard has been in 6 in that time. Yet still it’s Wayne Rooney who’s considered to be England’s superstar. Now the United bias in me has always maintained he is world class. The best English player around. Second only in world football to Ronaldo and Messi. But how can we honestly believe that? He has never been anywhere near being nominated for the Ballon d’Or. Both Lampard and Gerrard have finished in the top 3, so it’s no conspiracy against the English. He won the PFA Player of the Year Award in 2010 despite not being the league’s top scorer, nor playing for the league champions that season. Would he have won it were he not English? He’s played in 3 Champions League Finals and not shone in any. Despite winning it in 2008, he was substituted and, although it has since been denied by the player, and for obvious reasons forgotten about, he threw a tantrum on his way to the bench, throwing his shirt to the ground.

In England we have this bad habit of overhyping our promising players: Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain, Jack Wilshere, Theo Walcott are three recent examples. They are not superstars. They are (or were in the case of Walcott) talented young footballers with potential to be good, but great? Can you ever see them challenging for Europe’s top player awards? Are they in the same league as Neymar, Hazard or Christian Eriksen?  They’re English and talented so we automatically assume they’re world superstars. And it’s the same with Wayne Rooney. He was playing his best football in 2010. Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi were undoubtedly the two best players in the world, so Rooney had to have been number 3, right?

Wayne Rooney’s has bursts where he is unplayable. He’s a confidence player, no doubt. And he is extremely talented, no doubt, but has really become the player we expected him to be? This is not just a knee jerk reaction to last Monday’s performance. He was poor so often last season, and would often score a brace while having a very poor game. While we can find excuses to explain them all, he has never truly shone at a major tournament. In fact, he’s been dreadful at every single one. He’s never scored a world cup goal, and he’s never even looked like scoring one. I don’t think we should sell him as I think he is a very good; he’s just not the player we expected him to be prior to the 2006 World Cup. He’s nowhere near the top players in the world. Were we to sell him, do you really think we could get the same amount that Chelsea paid for Fernando Torres?

Follow me on twitter for more Red views @ACRUTD


28 responses to “Has Rooney Fulfilled His Potential?”

  1. hey says:

    Austin, I am not even English, I am just trying to say what my opinions are, afterall everyone is entitled to his own opinion. Rooney’s overall play and desire to play football is unbelievable. Even if he doesn’t score he helps to keep the team tick, he comes down to support the midfield and plays there attimes. Last time I checked he’s 4th in united all time scorer. He’s no Messi not Ronaldo, but he’s simply Wayne Rooney and I will say he’s done his best for both club and country. He’s a fighter and he will prove you all wrong

  2. Francis says:

    Why criticise dis young man…presently he may not be able to compete with messi or cr7 but is dia any hardworking player lyk rooney,if man u av a decent midfield lyk barca or madrid or perhaps if england av a gud passing midfield lyk spain….then rooney too could av excel upfront nd not continue to drop deeper nd deeper for d ball…u claimed stevie G is ur best english player in d last decade…since d departure of alonso nd masherano has he shown a great world class status….NO…cos he is nt a gud midfielder…he only enjoys playing behind d stike…

  3. Uche chukwuato says:

    Dis aticle is totally rubbish and for sumbodi sayin rooney scored against lesser oppositions,i want to knw weda scorin against barca,arsenal,liverpool or chelsea are no big feat,we all knw dat messi has neva scored against chelsea in his 11meetins so cut d crap man

  4. Correction says:

    He became on the most expensive teenager in football history – He became the most expensive*

  5. rodrigo says:

    messi or even cristiano have teams that play for them rooney doesnt have a squad the lvl barcelona or real madrid has, he some times saccrifices for the good of the team, maybe at a different team he would be what many expect of him, for now he is doing what he and ferguson need to be top of the premier league

  6. NathonW says:

    What you on about? Rooney is world class. Support your team you punk.

    Only joking mate – you make a very good point in a well written article.

    I do feel Rooney is actually ‘world class’ and I do believe he would get into most sides across Europe; but these dips in form he has are strange and to be recognised as a great, you cant have as many dips as he does.

    I hope bringing RVP in will be a kick up the arse in consistency, more than anything.

  7. Clayton says:

    Well in my opinion his problem is his lack of pace, excess weight and lack of dribbling skills that apparently he has forgotten from his younger years.

    He needs some heavy training. He’s still 26/27 though. He shouldn’t be so slow, and I agree with the comment that most defenders outpace him nowadays and apparently he can’t go past a defender. However his vision and passing can’t be complained about really.

    That said I miss the times where he played second fiddle to Ronaldo. Think those were his best years and that was his best position.

    I think if he works hard on this physique he shall be considered one of the greats once again.

  8. Rampant Red says:

    A measured article with some deep insights into the Rooney psyche. I am sick and tired of hearing people say ‘ Man U are spearheaded by an old potato head ‘ it’s unfair to Rooney and its unfair to potatos.

  9. Andrew says:

    Yeah I actually agree Rooney has not become the world class player we thought he would be when he signed in 2005. He is a talented footballer and we shouldn’t sell him, but he is not world class like Ronaldo or Messi. I think he has lost his way with the scandals with the cheating with other women and all those bad headlines. The signings of Kagawa and van Persie is a message that the team won’t be built around him anymore.

  10. Blue Tony says:

    Rampant Red has a point. It’s not just good old potato head that is letting down the mighty reds – it is the other vegetables. giggsy and Scholes are too ripe , Rvp is nearly too ripe and Sir Alex – well- withered prunes come to mind! Oh, that’s a fruit! My metaphor has become mixed! As I write it’s Southampton 1 DFSR’s 0. I think I’ll have some horseradish on this Beef!