Date: 17th November 2012 at 11:55pm
Written by:

Lindegaard – Couldn’t do much about the goal but always looked nervous when dealing with any aerial threats. His passing was all over the place, as per usual. 5

Rafael – Pegged back well into his own half and was unable to play his usual dynamic role of bombing up and down the touchline to support the attackers. 5

Smalling – Grew into the game and made several key interceptions. He looked miles better than he did against Villa. A few more games under his belt and he’ll be back to his best. 6

Ferdiand – Not his usual composed self as he was caught napping on more than one occasion. His legs seemed to be even slower than usual. 4

Evra – Not much wrong from him tonight when compared to his teammates. Didn’t look a liability which is something to be happy about since it’s not often you can say that. 5

Valencia – Can someone explain to me what he’s actually good at? He can’t shoot or score, his crossing is extremely inconsistent, he can’t beat a man, he doesn’t win you a match. ‘He tracks back’ I hear you ask? Well fuck-a-doodle-do. United’s #7 my arse. 3

Carrick – Not for the first time this season he has been a complete bystander. His brilliant form of last season looks long gone. 4

Giggs – I love Giggs. I really do. I just don’t know where his best position is though. He’s too old and slow to play in a midfield two, and not quick enough to play out wide. He shouldn’t be starting games in my opinion. Should only be used as a game-changer late on. 4

Young – Unlike Valencia, he very rarely gets hold of the ball. Also unlike Valencia, when he does get hold of it, he does look capable of producing something out of nothing, such is his ability to use both feet. 5

Van Persie – Looked out of it today without Rooney. He needs to be able to influence the game more when dropping deep as his job required he do more than just get us a goal. 4

Hernandez – Worked hard and always created space with clever movement. His effort in tracking back to help the defence was admirable. 5


Scholes- You know we were dreadful when even Paul Scholes couldn’t help us. 6

Welbeck – Why would you take a striker off who can’t stop scoring for another who hasn’t scored for United in quite a while? 5

Anderson – Meh. 5

(A lot of people tend to comment on these posts but I’m unable to respond to them via mobile. If you want, feel free to tweet me @Nashat_Hassan so I can answer your questions or reply to you comments. Thanks)


19 responses to “Player Ratings: United vs Norwich”

  1. rodrigo says:

    fergie needs to start acting like 26 years in united.. giggs is too old, he cant start over anderson or play wide when nani is in the bench, even fletcher is an opcion giggs is for local cup games lets hope chelsea take points from city and we still go unbeaten in CL

  2. si says:

    obviously giggs isnt da problem!!!1 he actually made a few great passes. but more importantly he was used against norwich in a squad rotation. if it was a big game he wouldn have started. the problem is carrick – hes not up to it. in the most important position in one of the biggest clubs in the world its staggering thats he gets the job. no 16!!!! if he had some bust up with fergie lets say and was to be sold – can u see barca real etc coming in for him? no. chelsea, city, arsenal no. pool spurs etc no. not even newcastle would go for him. be da likes of stoke sunderland. not good enough. he could be used as a squad player for united and be useful – but our number one midfielder!!! now its not his fault. its fergies for playin and trusting him and not replacing him. united have alot of great parts but no engine in the middle! no 16!!